Starr Insurance Agency

Our team is committed to providing the best possible service to you, your family & our community. Let us help you find the perfect plan for your needs.

Three certification badges: the first reads 'Best of Monroe County,' the second is 'Farm Bureau Insurance' endorsed by Kelsey Starr, and the third is the Blue Ribbon Award from the Office of Excellence.
Red and white sign with an icon of a document and shield, and text that reads "Report a Claim & Roadside Assistance."
A digital graphic with a red background on the left side featuring an icon of a document with a checkmark, and the text "Request a Quote" in bold on a white background on the right side.
Graphic with credit card icons on a red background and the text 'Pay Your Bill' in black on a white background.
Sign with a briefcase icon and the text 'Join Our Team' inviting people to join a team.
A black and white phone.
A black and white email.
A black and white chat bubble.
This is an icon of a smartphone with a black screen, rounded corners, and a thin white outline.

What Insurance Options Are Offered?

A black and white image of a house.

Home

House, condo, mobile home, rental, lake life, and more –wherever you call home, we have a policy to protect it.

A black and white image of a steering wheel.

Auto

No matter what you drive, we have a policy to keep you and your loved ones safe on the road.

A black and white silhouette of people.

Life

With policies for term and whole life, your assets are protected as long as you need it.

Black and white sketch of a brief case.
Black and white sketch of a briefcase.

Business

At The Starr Insurance Agency, we care about protecting your livelihood and what you love.

A black and white tractor.

Farm

When it comes to protecting your farm, trust the people that understand what’s important to farmers.

A black and white corn cob.

Crop

Farm Bureau Insurance offers crop insurance coverage that can provide you with peace of mind.

Testimonials

  • All the staff was very friendly. We worked with Sara, who answered all of our questions, and increased the replacement value of our garage, and still came in about $40 less per month than our previous insurance! We will pay the same monthly rate for cars and house for a year! That was impressive to us.

    - Rita Graves

  • I saved over $1500 on 3 policies. They explained everything well and were great to work with.

    - Laurie Tremonti

  • Professional and friendly. Answered any and all questions. My coverage is exactly what I was quoted!

    - Pam Howard

  • I was with Farm Bureau for 55-years (with a different agent) before leaving and going with two different companies in the last two years. Now I’m pleased to say I’m back with Farm Bureau and the Starr Agency. I want to give a big shout out to Ben, Kelsey and Sara for the attention they gave to my needs they are the best.

    - T Wick

  • Thanks again for EVERYTHING.  I would absolutely recommend your office for any insurance needs - you've been so very helpful and kind!

    — Lori LeGendre

  • I switched over my home and auto policies because their rates were better than 11 other quotes. Sara was a joy to work with and made the process easy.

    — George Hansen

  • Starr Insurance Agency helped me save money on my home & auto insurance. The ladies were very helpful, patient & efficient.

    — Marthel Allen

  • Sara worked her magic and save me a lil fat cash! She's very pleasant to work with also.

    Annette Maurer

  • Sara does a great job at explaining types of coverages and helping you decide what is best for you. She also worked to get me the maximum amount of discounts. I am a very happy customer.

    — Christy Rhoades

  • Great Agency! Everyone at the office is friendly, caring and willing to help and answer questions!

    — Amy Ash

  • I've been a member here on and off for around 30 years, my off months I didn't have a vehicle. I wouldn't go anywhere else.. the girls that work there treat me like family and are always friendly

    — Tamwicked

A group of five people, four women and one man, standing together and smiling at the camera at the Choice Awards event with a dark background and logos.

We pride ourselves on going above and beyond to give our customers exceptional service. We know our clients and we know insurance, so our clients have the peace of mind that comes with knowing their insurance agency can help them regardless of how big, small, unique, or specific their insurance needs are.  We offer a wide variety of auto, home, commercial/business, health/ medical, and life insurance. Our agent & staff are a group of wonderful people, that care about you.  

Learn More About Us
Learn More About Us